Skip to content
Robin Schreiner

UX Management · Product Leadership

← All notes

People · 4 min read

The UX shortcut that never existed

UX has deep roots and a confusing job market. A short course can open the door, but it cannot replace the work of learning how to solve people’s problems.

When people talk about the difficult UX job market, AI gets much of the attention. I wrote about what it might do to the path from junior to senior. But there is another part of this story: what have we been telling people it takes to become a UX professional?

For years, the field looked like a fast way into a creative career. Learn a tool, complete an online course, collect a certificate, build a few polished screens, and apply for a UX/UI Designer role. I understand why that promise was attractive. I also think it left many people with the wrong idea of what the work involves.

Old foundations, newer labels

Usability is not a new idea. The field has years of research, practice, and standards behind it. ISO 9241-11 gives us a framework for understanding usability, while ISO 9241-210 describes principles and activities for human-centred design. None of this appeared when someone added “UX” to a job title.

UX as a professional label is broader and less consistent. One company means research and product strategy. Another means interaction design. A third wants someone to make a screen look good and calls the role “UX/UI.” UI matters, of course. It is part of an experience. But a good-looking interface does not tell us whether we understood the right problem, designed a useful service, or helped someone achieve their goal.

The unclear titles make it harder for beginners to know what they need to learn. They also make it easier to sell a shortcut.

A certificate is a start, not a career

A two-week course can introduce a method or help someone decide whether they want to explore UX further. That is valuable. It cannot give someone the judgment that comes from interviewing people, making a wrong assumption, testing a solution, and dealing with what happens after release.

UX is more methodical than its polished outputs suggest. You need to understand people in context, work with incomplete evidence, involve other disciplines, and make trade-offs between user needs, business goals, and technical constraints. You also need to know when a method is useful and when you are only following a template because it came with the course.

I do not blame someone for believing the promise of a fast track. If we advertise a complex profession as something you can master in a few weeks, the problem is the promise. The work still has to be learned.

A hard market is not a skills test

There is economic pressure on teams. AI is changing which tasks companies expect one person to handle. The broad and sometimes confusing definition of UX has also brought people into roles with very different levels of preparation. I think all of this contributes to the competition we see now.

But I would be careful with the idea that the market is simply “clearing out” people who do not belong. Losing a role does not prove someone lacks skill. Good people are affected by budgets, reorganisations, location, timing, and hiring decisions they cannot control. Nor does a degree automatically make someone better at the work than a self-taught designer.

What I do see, from my experience at Siemens, is continued demand for people who can do the work well. People who can ask the right questions, choose an appropriate method, work with others, and show what changed because they were involved. The opportunities are there, but the standard is demanding.

Show the problem, not just the screen

Competition makes it tempting to polish a portfolio until it looks like a gallery. A shiny dashboard on Dribbble or social media can show visual skill. It tells me little about how you work when the brief is unclear or when the first idea fails.

I would rather see one honest case story: What was the problem? Who had it? What did you believe at the start? How did you find out you were wrong? Which options did you reject, and why? What happened when the solution met real people, real constraints, or real product data?

If you used AI, show that too. Tell me what you delegated, what you checked, and where your judgment changed the result. That says more about your ability than pretending you made every pixel by hand.

Curiosity is still the starting point. Be interested in people and in solving problems that matter to them. Add the willingness to understand how a product works as a business, and an entrepreneurial spirit to try things before anyone hands you a perfect brief. Those qualities do not remove the economic pressure or make competition easy. They give you a way to keep growing through it.

There is no fast lane to becoming good at UX. There is a path: do the work, learn from what does not work, and get curious enough to try again.

Keep reading

Who becomes senior when AI does the junior work?